INFORMATION ABOUT PROJECT,
SUPPORTED BY RUSSIAN SCIENCE FOUNDATION

The information is prepared on the basis of data from the information-analytical system RSF, informative part is represented in the author's edition. All rights belong to the authors, the use or reprinting of materials is permitted only with the prior consent of the authors.

 

COMMON PART


Project Number22-13-00151

Project titleOn the microscopic theory of the formation of thermodynamically stable bubbles and droplets near a solid surface

Project LeadPismak Yury

AffiliationFederal State Budgetary Educational Institution of Higher Education "Saint-Petersburg State University",

Implementation period 2022 - 2024 

Research area 03 - CHEMISTRY AND MATERIAL SCIENCES, 03-406 - Chemical thermodynamics. Physical chemistry of the surface and interphase boundaries. Adsorption

Keywordsdroplets, bubbles, wetting, hydrophobicity, density functional method, nucleation, adsorption, disjoining pressure, liquid films, surface tension, line tension


 

PROJECT CONTENT


Annotation
Formation of thermodynamically stable droplets and bubbles near solid surfaces is one of the topical issues in the science of surface phenomena, attracting the attention of many researchers in the last decade. Solving this question is of fundamental importance for further development of theory and practical applications related to heterogeneous nucleation in gases and liquids, efficient separation of substances and creation of nano- and microcontainers, with applications for inkjet printing and in the design of microfluidic devices. In particular, the existence of thermodynamically stable droplets or bubbles during nucleation provides an opportunity to strongly lower the nucleation threshold. Note that during homogeneous nucleation there are no stable droplets in a bulk vapor or stable gas bubbles in a bulk liquid, and their appearance is possible either in a small confined system or in the presence of heterogeneous centers or surfaces. An accompanying problem of the formation of stable droplets and bubbles near solid surfaces is the question of the disjoining pressure in such droplets and bubbles due to their strong heterogeneity. One of the modern methods for studying highly inhomogeneous systems is the classical density functional theory (DFT), which has recently been used in various variants to describe surface layers both at solid–liquid and liquid–vapor interfaces. Other widely used methods are molecular dynamic simulations and the Monte Carlo method. In addition, the nudged elastic band (NEB) computational method has recently been effectively developed in application to problems where an energy hypersurface analysis in high or infinite dimensional space is required. This numerical method allows to find the minimum energy path (MEP) that the system "passes" from the initial unstable or metastable state to the final, stable state. This method is applicable to systems with different geometry. To the present date, the existence of thermodynamically stable spherical small droplets in the form of liquid films around lyophilic solid nano- and microparticles can be considered confirmed, but questions about the local structure and disjoining pressure in such films remain open.The project participants have recently shown for the first time, on the basis of the gradient DFT, that stable but very narrow flat or spherical vapor layers corresponding to minima of the grand thermodynamic potential of the system are formed near a strongly lyophilic surface of a solid in a stretched liquid. The presence of disjoining pressure in such interlayers was also detected. The results obtained for stable and unstable gas phase embryos are consistent with earlier general thermodynamic predictions based on the analysis of the role of disjoining pressure in thin heterogeneous films and the theory of heterogeneous nucleation on wettable condensation nuclei. However, the gradient DFT has quite a low accuracy and gives rather qualitative predictions, especially when dealing with oscillating density profiles in the liquid near the solid wall. To obtain a reliable result, we need to turn to a full integral DFT taking into account the non-local hard-sphere contribution to the free energy of the system. The task of directly determining the structure of a thin liquid or vapor shell using all-atom and coarse-grained molecular dynamics also remains relevant. A special place is occupied by the question of rigorous calculation of the fluctuating electromagnetic field tensor, free energy, and Casimir–Polder potential in heterogeneous systems in the presence of thin films, droplets, bubbles, vacuum, and air gaps. Simple molecular field integrations for solids can introduce uncontrollable errors. Based on the results previously obtained by the project participants, the project is supposed to obtain a solution to the following new 8 problems in a three-year period: 1. Taking into account hard-sphere correlations (non-locality of the free energy of a system of molecules as hard spheres) in calculations for spherical droplets and bubbles on small solid particles within the full integral density functional theory (fundamental measure DFT). 2. Investigation of the equilibrium of planar and spherical solid surfaces in contact with a sessile droplet and bubble using the gradient and full integral DFT, the nudged elastic band method, and analysis of the transition from lyophilic to lyophobic surfaces. 3. Finding a solution within the DFT for two-component liquids with special interest in solvent + lyophobic component type systems (including the case when this component can be predominantly adsorbed at the surface). 4. Establishing relation between interface displacement models dealing with a functional of the interface displacement (layer thickness) profiles, and DFT-based descriptions; calculation of the interface potential (and, respectively, the disjoining pressure isotherm) for use with interface displacement models. 5. Calculation of the contact angles of sessile droplets and bubbles, surface and line tension with use of the obtained models of the interface potential. 6. Improving equations of state of bulk fluids based on the Rusanov equations (for single-component and then for binary systems) for DFT applications. 7. Calculation of the contact angle for a water droplet on planar hydrophilic and hydrophobic surfaces by the molecular dynamics method within the all-atom model. Carrying out all-atom molecular dynamics modeling of a water film on a nanoscale spherical particle with a hydrophilic surface. Building a coarse-grained model based on all-atom modeling data of a system consisting of a spherical particle surrounded by water molecules using the inverse Monte Carlo method. Simulation of the formation of a bubble near a nanoscale spherical particle by the Monte Carlo method in the isothermal-isobaric statistical ensemble using the coarse-grained model. 8. Developing a method for calculating the fluctuating electromagnetic field tensor, free energy and Casimir–Polder potential in inhomogeneous systems in the presence of thin films, droplets, bubbles, vacuum and air gaps. Analysis of the dependences of the free energy and the Casimir–Polder potential on the geometric characteristics of the systems and the properties of the materials, calculations of the stable geometric configurations of the systems and to establishing a relationship with the disjoining pressure.

Expected results
The following results are expected: 1. The molecular structure and the disjoining pressure in spherical droplets and bubbles on small solid particles will be described when taking into account hard-sphere correlations within the full integral density functional theory (DFT). In this way, the most complete answer about spherical thermodynamically stable bubbles and droplets will be obtained. The results obtained here will be used in the remaining problems of the project. 2. The transition from lyophilic to lyophobic surfaces and the accompanying transition from droplets to bubbles with a possible change in their geometry and the transition from sessile droplets to concentric films will be analyzed. This is one of the central tasks of the project. 3. Density profiles for two-component liquid–solid interlayers will be found. The volume of the gas layer near the solid particle and its dependence on the particle size and characteristics of its surface will be evaluated. 4. Relation between interface displacement models and the DFT-based description will be established; the interface potential (and, consequently, the disjoining pressure isotherm) will be calculated within DFT for use with interface displacement models. The result will be used in solving problem 5 of the project. 5. Using the obtained model interface potentials, contact angles for sessile droplets and bubbles, surface and line tension will be calculated within an interface displacement model. 6. Refined equations of state for bulk fluid phases based on the Rusanov equations will be applied (first in single-component and then in binary systems) to the full integral DFT in calculations for bubbles and droplets. 7. The contact angle for a water droplet on planar hydrophilic and hydrophobic surfaces will be calculated by molecular dynamics within the all-atom model. An all-atom molecular dynamics modeling of the water film on a nanoscale spherical particle with a hydrophilic surface will be performed. The results will be compared with the results of problems 1 and 2. A coarse-grained model of the system consisting of a spherical particle surrounded by water molecules will be built based on the all-atom modeling data using the inverse Monte Carlo method. А Monte Carlo modeling of bubble formation near the nanoscale spherical particle will be performed in the isothermal-isobaric statistical ensemble using the coarse-grained model. 8. A method for calculating the fluctuating electromagnetic field tensor, the free energy and the Casimir–Polder potential in heterogeneous systems in the presence of thin films, droplets, bubbles, vacuum and air gaps will be formulated. The dependences of the free energy and the Casimir–Polder potential on the geometric characteristics of the systems and the material properties will be analysed, the stable geometric configurations of the systems will be calculated and the relationship with the disjoining pressure will be established. These results will be new and will correspond to the world level of research.


 

REPORTS


Annotation of the results obtained in 2022
Recently, using the gradient and integral molecular density functional method, we have shown that not only stable droplets are formed from vapor around solid lyophilic particles, but also thin stable concentric vapor shells-bubbles appear around lyophobic particles in a stretched liquid. Such droplets and bubbles correspond to local minima of the grand thermodynamic potential of the system with the new phase nucleus, the initial phase, and the nucleation seed. One of the objectives of our work within the framework of the RSF grant is to study stable droplets and bubbles on lyophilic and lyophobic nucleation seeds using the modern molecular density functional method with the most complete allowance for hard-sphere correlations in terms of fundamental measure theory. Within this approach, equilibrium three-dimensional density profiles of droplets around solid lyophilic spherical particles in undersaturated and supersaturated vapor and thin concentric vapor shells on lyophobic particles in a stretched and stable liquid were calculated in 2022. The existence of enveloping stable droplets and bubbles on nanosized lyophilic and lyophobic nucleation seeds has been confirmed, the structure of droplets and bubbles has been described, dependences of the chemical potential of molecules in a droplet and in a bubble on the thickness of a liquid or vapor film have been plotted, and the threshold values of the chemical potential of vapor and liquid for barrier-free heterogeneous nucleation have been found. With the help of the expression for a grand thermodynamic potential as a molecular density functional, the disjoining pressures in thin liquid films around nanosized wettable spherical particles and in thin vapor layers around nonwettable particles are calculated depending on the energy parameters of molecular interactions, film thickness, and particle size. Although the results show a qualitative agreement between the calculated dependences of the disjoining pressure and those obtained in the framework of a simpler gradient method of the molecular density functional, the new results differ significantly quantitatively. It has been confirmed that the disjoining pressure in a liquid film around a nanosized lyophilic particle increases with an increase in particle size and lyophilicity. When studying inhomogeneous fluids using the density functional theory in many of its variants, one employs expressions for the local free energy, as well as for the chemical potential in a system of hard spheres without attraction as functions of the concentration of the hard spheres. Exact expressions for these functions are unknown, but there are various approximations that demonstrate different accuracy. In 2022, we have considered and compare the results given by the Carnahan–Starling, the Percus–Yevik, the Kolafa equations of state, and the 6th and the 7th-order Rusanov equations of state for a system of hard spheres without attraction. The dependences of the compressibility factor, chemical potential, and free energy density on the particle number density have been considered and compared with the modified Kolafa–Labík–Malijevský equation describing results of molecular dynamics simulations of the compressibility factor with high accuracy, though in a limited density range. We have calculated, within the integral density functional theory in random-phase approximation, the molecular density profiles in radially inhomogeneous small spherical droplets and bubbles of an argon-like substance representing critical droplets/bubbles in nucleation. We have such calculations for the Carnahan–Starling, Kolafa and truncated 6th-order Rusanov equations of state for hard spheres, as well as for the modified Kolafa–Labík–Malijevský equation. To describe the fluid, all the employed equations of state were supplemented with a term describing the attraction of particles in a mean-field approximation. When comparing the equations of state for a system of hard spheres to describe both a homogeneous fluid and critical droplets/bubbles, the Kolafa equation turned out to be the best of the considered equations of state for a system of hard spheres, repeating the results for the “reference” Kolafa–Labík–Malijevský equation with high accuracy. At the same time, the Kolafa equation is much simpler and resembles the widely used Carnahan–Starling equation, significantly exceeding it in accuracy in describing both homogeneous and inhomogeneous fluids of hard spheres. The increase in performance of computing equipment as well as its accessibility to scientific community inevitably leads to more and more frequent use of molecular modeling methods, such as molecular dynamics and Monte Carlo methods, for tackling the fundamental and applied scientific problems. These problems certainly include the studies of the properties of sessile droplets on the surfaces of different structure and chemical composition. One of the most important properties of the surface is its wettability, because its modification opens up wide opportunities for practical applications. In 2022, using the molecular dynamics method, we simulated the formation of a sessile droplet on a flat surface and calculated its contact angle which is the macroscopic characteristic of the surface wettability. Two methods for calculating the contact angle differing in the clustering procedure (i.e., separation of the molecules constituting the droplet from the molecules of the gas phase) were used. The droplets consisting of argon or water molecules were considered. An impenetrable wall interacting with a drop according to the Steele potential (“3-9” potential) was used as a flat surface, as well as the all-atom models of graphite and cristobalite (SiO2). For all the considered models of the surface we varied the degree of its wettability. The dependences of the contact angle of a droplet on its size and temperature were studied. As is known, the question of rigorous calculation of the stress tensor of a fluctuating electromagnetic field, free energy, and the Casimir–Polder potential in inhomogeneous systems in the presence of thin films, drops, bubbles, vacuum and air slots is of fundamental importance. Simple molecular field integrations for solids can introduce uncontrollable errors. An important task of this project is to study the dependence of free energy and the Casimir–Polder potential on the geometric characteristics of systems and on the physical and chemical properties of materials. In 2022, the theory of the Casimir effect was considered for two diffraction gratings separated by a vacuum slit. Discontinuity in the Casimir energy during rotation of the grating is shown to be the consequence of the fundamental transformation of structure of reciprocal vector space, which is a result of translational symmetry breaking. A novel explicitly gauge-invariant method for derivation of electric and magnetic Green functions in the Casimir effect theory is developed. The method is based on application of Weyl formula and makes it possible to derive the Casimir pressure and the Casimir-Polder potential of an anisotropic atom by a solution of an explicit gauge-invariant system of equations following from transversality of fields and boundary conditions.

 

Publications

1. Marachevsky V.N. Эффект Казимира для дифракционных решеток, нарушение симметрии и геометрические переходы Письма в журнал "Физика элементарных частиц и атомного ядра", - (year - 2023)

2. Shchekin A.K., Gosteva L.A. РАСКЛИНИВАЮЩЕЕ ДАВЛЕНИЕ В ТОНКИХ СФЕРИЧЕСКИХ ЖИДКИХ И ПАРОВЫХ ПЛЁНКАХ ПРИ УЧЁТЕ МОЛЕКУЛЯРНЫХ КОРРЕЛЯЦИЙ Доклады Российской академии наук. Химия, науки о материалах, - (year - 2023)

3. Shchekin A.K. Термодинамически устойчивые нанокапельки и нанопузырьки Известия Академии наук. Серия химическая, т.72, №2 (year - 2023)


Annotation of the results obtained in 2023
When describing nucleation of droplets in supersaturated vapor, it is usually assumed that a single nucleated droplet is very small compared to the size of the system and cannot noticeably affect the vapor properties. However, a confined system in the form of a small-sized cell is often used in nucleation modeling. In this case, there is an effect of a significant decrease in the concentration of the vapor molecules in the cell during the formation of a new phase embryo. A similar effect exists when calculations are carried out in the framework of, for example, the density functional method using the canonical ensemble. We have considered thermodynamics of droplet nucleation on a solid spherical particle in a supersaturated vapor first at macroscopic level of description using the disjoining pressure in the liquid film, and then using two variants of the classical density functional theory on lyophilic and lyophobic molecular-sized particles. Two modes, depending on the parameters, are found: (1) with an only stable droplet and (2) with three equilibrium droplets, the smallest and largest one being stable and the third one being critical. The appearance of the second (larger) stable droplet is a consequence of the confinement. At a small total number of molecules on the lyophobic particle, a sessile-droplet shaped solution is obtained. It is stable in the canonical ensemble but can correspond to a critical one in the grand canonical ensemble. This makes it possible to calculate the density distributions and characteristics of critical droplets or bubbles, including sessile ones, by minimizing a functional in the canonical ensemble instead of searching for a saddle point in the grand canonical ensemble. This significantly accelerates the calculations and increases their accuracy. In the study of the diffusive growth of gas bubbles and the evolution of their size distribution in gas-saturated solution, the role of the joint effects of capillarity and viscosity has been revealed, that, via the pressure inside the bubble, slow down the transition to stationary or self-similar regimes and may even prevent their establishment at the nucleation stage, making the bubble growth rate essentially non-stationary. They can also noticeably affect the distribution of supercritical gas bubbles during degassing of the solution at the nucleation stage. Thus, an increase in the solution viscosity provides a slowdown in the growth of bubbles of maximum and average size, as well as in the growth rate of the swelling coefficient of the whole solution. Thus, an increase in the solution viscosity provides a slowdown in the growth of bubbles of maximum and average size, as well as in the growth rate of the swelling coefficient of the whole solution. When the solution viscosity is increased by five decimal orders of magnitude at a fixed diffusion coefficient, viscosity has a damping effect on the growth rate of the average bubble radius and the swelling rate by a factor of two and, accordingly, doubles the time of the nucleation stage. Taking into account the feedback between the diffusion coefficient and viscosity, we found a much stronger inhibition by a decimal order when the solution viscosity is changed by three decimal orders. In spite of the fact that the self-similar theory of diffusional growth of a bubble cannot be directly applied at large viscosities, many of its features are preserved. The results obtained allow us to consider any specific system for which the physicochemical parameters, such as gas solubility, surface tension, diffusion and viscosity coefficients, nucleation rate, and work of formation are self-consistent. At present, such a set of values can only be obtained experimentally. Several methods based on density profiles and on Sobel filters have been applied to calculate contact angles of sessile droplets on planar surfaces using the data obtained from molecular dynamics simulations. Using these methods, the contact angles of argon and water droplets with sizes ranging from 1 to 10 nm have been determined. The dependencies of the contact angle on the droplet size were analyzed using the generalized Young equation, the values of both the line tension and the macroscopic contact angle were obtained. Molecular dynamics simulations of the nucleation of argon molecules on solid spherical particles with atomistic structure have been carried out. By varying the parameters of interaction between molecules of the fluid and these molecules with the spherical particle, we were able to adjust the degree of lyophilicity/lyophobicity of the particle and to observe both spherically symmetric liquid films and sessile droplets on the surface of the spherical particle. This important result, obtained by molecular dynamics modeling, confirmed the possibility of observing spherically asymmetric configurations of the “spherical particle – droplet” systems predicted in this project via the density functional method. All-atom molecular dynamics simulations of water films of different thicknesses on a nanoscale hydrophilic spherical particle consisting of silver atoms were also carried out, and the dependence of the chemical potential of a water molecule on the number of water molecules in the liquid film was obtained. The article [V.N. Marachevsky, A.A. Sidelnikov, “Gauge-invariant derivation of the Casimir–Lifshitz pressure”, Phys. Part. Nuclei Lett., 2023, v. 20, No. 5, pp. 1114–1116] presents a new gauge-invariant derivation of electrical Green’s functions in the gap between two dielectric half-spaces. The article also provides a derivation of the Casimir–Lifshitz pressure in this system. In the article [V.N. Marachevsky, A.A. Sidelnikov, “Casimir–Polder interaction with Chern–Simons boundary layers”, Phys. Rev. D, 2023, v. 107, 105019] published in a 1st quartile journal, the case of rotation of polarizations upon reflection of an electromagnetic field from systems with Chern–Simons flat boundary layers on a dielectric substrate is considered. In the article, a new analytical result for the Casimir–Polder potential of an anisotropic atom (molecule) in the presence of a flat Chern–Simons layer on the boundary of a dielectric half-space obtained, generalizing the result for the Casimir–Polder potential of an anisotropic atom in the presence of a flat Chern–Simons layer in vacuum, obtained in the work [V.N. Marachevsky, Yu.M. Pis’mak, “Casimir–Polder effect for a plane with Chern–Simons interaction”, Phys. Rev. D, 2010, v. 81, 065005]. Further in the article, new analytical results are obtained for the Casimir–Polder potential of an anisotropic atom (molecule) located in a vacuum gap between two dielectric half-spaces with boundary plane-parallel Chern–Simons layers. The results obtained for the Casimir–Polder potential have a remarkable property discovered for the first time: when one of the Chern–Simons layers is rotated by 180 degrees, the expression for the Casimir–Polder potential of an atom takes on a different value. We emphasize that in the calculation of the Casimir–Polder potential, the neutral atom (molecule) is described in the point dipole approximation within the framework of quantum electrodynamics.

 

Publications

1. Gosteva L.A., Shchekin A.K. Density Functional Theory with Fundamental Measure Theory for Stable Drops and Bubbles on Lyophilic and Lyophobic Nucleation Cores Physics of Particles and Nuclei Letters, Phys. Part. Nuclei Lett., 2023, v. 20, No. 5, p. 1084–1087 (year - 2023) https://doi.org/10.1134/S154747712305031X

2. Marachevsky V.N., Sidelnikov A.A. Casimir–Polder interaction with Chern–Simons boundary layers Physical Review D, Phys. Rev. D, 2023, v. 107, No. 10, 105019 (year - 2023) https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.107.105019

3. Marachevsky V.N., Sidelnikov A.A. Gauge-Invariant Derivation of the Casimir–Lifshitz Pressure Physics of Particles and Nuclei Letters, Phys. Part. Nuclei Lett., 2023, v. 20, No. 5, p. 1114–1116 (year - 2023) https://doi.org/10.1134/S1547477123050527

4. Shchekin A.K., Kuchma A.E., Aksenova E.V. The Effects of Viscosity and Capillarity on Nonequilibrium Distribution of Gas Bubbles in Swelling Liquid–Gas Solution Colloids and Interfaces, Colloids and Interfaces, 2023, v. 7, No. 2, 39 (year - 2023) https://doi.org/10.3390/colloids7020039